Data You Can Trust
Metal vs. Asphalt Shingles in Colorado: Making the Right Call
38
billion-dollar hailstorms in Colorado 1980–2024
NOAA
$1.9B
damage from May 2024 Front Range hailstorm
NOAA
96%
ROI on a minor kitchen remodel at resale
2025 Cost vs. Value Report
86%
of basement finishing costs recovered at resale
NAR / NARI Report
“After 11 years roofing in Colorado I’ve installed thousands of squares of both. Metal costs 2–3x more upfront but the total cost of ownership over 40–50 years often flips the equation — especially in hail-heavy areas where asphalt needs replacement every 15–20 years.”
Josh Brooks
Licensed General Contractor CON-24-0152 | Northern Colorado Since 2014
Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles
Colorado Cost & Performance Comparison
Unbiased comparison of Colorado’s two most popular roofing materials. Lifetime cost, hail resistance, insurance savings, and ROI — all explained.
We install both — get a written estimate for each and compare.
Full Comparison — Metal vs Asphalt in Colorado
| Factor | Standing Seam Metal | Class 4 Asphalt | Standard Asphalt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Installed Cost (Colorado) | $14,000–$38,000 | $10,000–$22,000 | $8,500–$18,000 |
| Lifespan | 40–70 years | 20–30 years | 15–25 years |
| Hail Resistance | Class 4 ✓ | Class 4 ✓ | Class 1–3 |
| Insurance Discount | 20–35% | 15–25% | None |
| Energy Efficiency | Excellent — reflects UV | Good | Average |
| Maintenance | Very low — inspect annually | Low | Moderate |
| Lifetime Cost (50 yrs) | $26,000–$45,000 | $28,000–$44,000 | $34,000–$54,000 |
| Best For Colorado | Long-term owners & mountain homes | Insurance claims & mid-term owners | Budget-driven replacement |
* Lifetime cost includes 50-year period. Insurance discounts applied. Assumes standard Front Range home.
Choose Metal Roofing If:
- ✓ You plan to stay 15+ years — lifetime cost advantage kicks in
- ✓ Mountain or foothill home — snow loads and wind favor metal
- ✓ Energy efficiency matters — metal reflects 70%+ of solar heat
- ✓ Maximum insurance savings — 20-35% premium reduction
- ✓ You hate roofing contractors — never replace it again in your lifetime
Choose Class 4 Asphalt If:
- ✓ Upgrading through insurance — best cost/performance on a claim
- ✓ Planning to sell in 5–15 years — strong ROI at resale
- ✓ HOA restricts metal — many Colorado HOAs prohibit standing seam
- ✓ Budget is the primary driver — lowest upfront cost
- ✓ Traditional home aesthetic — asphalt has more color/style options
Colorado Roofing Questions
Is metal roofing worth the extra cost in Colorado?
Yes for most Colorado homes. Metal roofing costs 2-3x more upfront but lasts 40-70 years versus 15-25 for asphalt. Colorado’s hail means asphalt is replaced every 15-20 years on average. Insurance discounts of 20-35% for Class 4 metal further improve the ROI. For homeowners planning to stay 15+ years, metal is typically the better lifetime investment.
How much more does metal roofing cost than asphalt in Colorado?
Standing seam metal runs $14,000–$38,000 installed. Class 4 asphalt runs $10,000–$22,000. Standard asphalt runs $8,500–$18,000. The gap on a typical Colorado home is $8,000–$16,000 upfront. That gap closes significantly when you factor in asphalt’s 15-25 year replacement cycle and metal’s 40-70 year lifespan — metal often wins on lifetime cost.
Does HOA allow metal roofing in Colorado?
It depends on the HOA. Many Colorado HOAs allow standing seam metal in dark colors but prohibit bright or corrugated metal. Metal shingles (which look like asphalt) are allowed in most HOAs. Josh Brooks Construction and Renovation Inc. reviews your HOA covenants during the estimate process and recommends products that comply. We install both standing seam and metal shingles.
Can insurance pay for a metal roof upgrade in Colorado?
Yes. When hail damages your asphalt roof, insurance pays the like-for-like replacement cost. You pay the upgrade difference to metal — typically $8,000–$18,000 out of pocket. Josh Brooks Construction and Renovation Inc. documents all damage, attends your adjuster meeting, and manages the entire upgrade process. Many Colorado homeowners upgrade to metal this way.
Get Written Estimates for Both Metal and Asphalt
We install both. Compare real pricing side by side. Serving all of Northern Colorado.
📞 720-828-7997💬 Text UsOnline Quote
CON-24-0152 • $1M/$2M Insured • Senior & Veteran Discounts
Roofing Services Across Colorado
📍 Hail Damage Boulder CO
📍 Hail Damage Erie CO
📍 Hail Damage Fort Collins CO
📍 Hail Damage Greeley CO
📍 Hail Damage Loveland CO
📍 Hail Damage Arvada CO
📍 Hail Damage Westminster CO
📍 Hail Damage Broomfield CO
📍 Hail Damage Thornton CO
📍 Hail Damage Brighton CO
📍 Hail Damage Highlands Ranch CO
📍 Hail Damage Lafayette CO
📍 Hail Damage Louisville CO
📍 Hail Damage Johnstown CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Aurora CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Commerce City CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Golden CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Berthoud CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Fort Morgan CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Sterling CO
📍 Roofing Contractor Franktown CO
⭐ Best Roofing Companies Longmont CO
⭐ Insurance Roof Claim Boulder CO
⭐ Hail Damage Roof Replacement Boulder County
⭐ Roof Replacement Jefferson County CO
⭐ Metal Roofing Colorado
⭐ Metal Roofing Cost Colorado 2026
BY THE NUMBERS
Why Colorado Homeowners Act Fast After a Storm
“I’ve been working roofs in Northern Colorado since 2014. I’ve seen hail take a perfectly maintained 20-year-old roof from functional to failing in a single afternoon — and most homeowners don’t even know until their ceiling starts dripping two months later. Get it inspected before the insurance window closes.”
— Josh Brooks, Licensed General Contractor & Roofer — License CON-24-0152
